History
The Gates Riot of 1887
When the Hellhole Nearly Broke Open
Part 1: The Butcher Knife Ambush
On the morning of October 27, 1887, the Yuma Territorial Prison was under the leadership of Superintendent Thomas Gates. It was a typical, blistering morning until a group of seven desperate inmates decided to test the "impossible to escape" reputation of the granite fortress.
The leaders of the escape were some of the most dangerous men in the yard: Luz Hernandez, Puebla, and Lopez. The plan was simple and brutal: seize the Superintendent, use him as a shield, and walk right out the front gate.
As Superintendent Gates was conducting an inspection near the prison shops, the inmates made their move. Hernandez, armed with a smuggled butcher knife, lunged at Gates. In the ensuing struggle, Gates was stabbed multiple times in the neck and back.
With the Superintendent bleeding and held at knife-point, the group began a slow, tense march toward the main gate. The guards in the towers were paralyzed; they had their Gatling guns and rifles trained on the group, but they couldn't fire without killing their own boss.
Part 2: The Heroism of Barney Riggs
Among the crowd of prisoners watching the chaos was Barney Riggs. Riggs was not a hero by any traditional measure; he was a convicted murderer serving a life sentence for killing a man in a saloon fight.
As he watched Hernandez and the others prepare to execute Gates once they cleared the walls, Riggs made a split-second decision that would change Arizona history.
Riggs lunged for a pistol. Positioning himself with a clear line of sight, Riggs did what the guards couldn't. He opened fire on the ringleaders.
Riggs shot Luz Hernandez, the man holding the knife to Gates' throat, killing him instantly. In the confusion, Riggs and the tower guards opened fire on the rest of the conspirators.
When the smoke cleared, four of the seven escapees lay dead or dying in the dirt. Superintendent Gates was alive, though barely.
The Arizona Territory was stunned. The idea of a "lifer" saving the man who kept him in a cage was unheard of. In recognition of his bravery, Barney Riggs was granted a full pardon by the Governor and walked out of the Yuma Territorial Prison a free man just a few months later.
Part 3: The Ghost of Thomas Gates
Superintendent Thomas Gates survived the initial stabbing, but he was never the same man. The physical and psychological toll was immense.
The trauma haunted him for nearly ten years. Tragically, in 1896, the man who had faced down a riot and survived an ambush took his own life in the prison hospital. His death cast a somber pall over the institution.
For the surviving inmates who participated in the riot, the consequences were severe. They were moved to the "Dark Cell"—a windowless, iron-lined dungeon carved into the rock.
Today, the Yuma Territorial Prison is one of Arizona's most visited historical sites, but it is also considered one of the most haunted. Paranormal investigators and visitors continue to report strange occurrences near the main gate and the hospital wing where Gates passed away.
Many believe the spirit of Thomas Gates still paces the yard, forever on his morning inspection, while others claim to hear the phantom echoes of the 1887 gunfire near the Sallyport.